(Text post)
The big buzz over the last two days has been the news (From MWGblog) that MommyCast is no longer with Podshow. Before we all pile on the “Podshow sucks” bandwagon, let’s be honest about our feelings on the subject: We tend to dislike ‘corporate organizations,’ and we tend to favor ‘independent success.’
Having just now performed that bit of perception filtering on myself, I am still left with a sense of antagonism towards Podshow. I know that Podshow is making failed attempts to separate themselves from the core community, and I also know that podcasters are growing weary of the manufactured and unilateral animosity. Podshow is creating an environment in which the emotional attachments between them and their podcast producers fade quickly, leaving only legal contractual obligations. It’s been my experience that “legal contractual obligations” do not inspire the passion required to produce quality content.
*I pause a moment to refresh my objectivity filter.* While I was at the 2006 Podcast Expo, I had an all-too-brief-before-the-plane-leaves conversation with the new owner of a new podcast network, and I think I startled him with my views on what it takes to really succeed in this market. He is a smart man, and he is just now beginning to understand the nuances of the podcasting marketplace and its many (sometimes subtle) differences between podcasts and radio.
I know that he (and everyone else) will fail if he tries to apply existing/traditional media models to podcasting. His only hope is to re-imagine his business using non-media models (I suggested a mix of “the creativity of niche comic books/graphic novels, the passion and willingness to spend money of model rocketry clubs, the streamlining of production of CafePress, and the narrow-cast monetization strategy of Google AdSense”)
Regarding ad networks, content valuations, and content ownership: If you listen to Podcheck, you know that I have some well-expressed views on the subject of Podcasters’ power to control their own destinies, and no one seems to be helping the podcasters achieve the PODCASTERS’ monetary and social goals. Where is the niche advertising, narrowly-targeted audience messages pertinent to the subject material, and monetary rewards reflective of the audience participation?
So far, every company in the podcast-marketing-network space has failed to live up to my expectations, yet Podshow stands out as being the least-likeable. Considering their anti-involvement in the grass-roots community, and their big “F*** You” to the Podcast Expo attendees (in the form of a giant black Hummer Limo to shuttle the chosen few between the actual event and their anti-event), this aire of disdain is Podshow’s own fault. At least Podtrac had a “member meeting” and parties on site, and Kiptronic had a party or two. The muckety-mucks of both Podtrac and Kiptronic made themselves available for ANYONE to discuss ANYTHING.
I also suspect that more podcasts will leave Podshow in the next 18-24 months. (Eric Rice has a similar take on it.) More importantly, I suspect that new podcasters will avoid a Podshow deal. Podshow needs to consider some changes, including an initiative to do some outreach to counter this increasingly well-formed argument pervasive antagonism against them.
In any event, best wishes to Paige and Gretchen of The MommyCast!
UPDATE 10/29/2006: According to P.W. Fenton, Podshow was not allowed to rent space at the Marriott Hotel, which “forced” them to hold their activities elsewhere. I still believe that this was the result of a choice that was made by Podshow to not pay for the necessary booth, sponsorship, whatever at the Expo. How is it that companies like Podango, Kiptronic, Blubrry, and others can manage to navigate the supposedly treacherous political waters of the Expo, and Podshow is an outcast?
I have re-read this post, and I see that it does not reflect my best efforts. It is bitter, scatological, and weakly-threaded. Still, I was so moved by something that I spent more than a few minutes that night to type the post. I have run out of time to analyze my motivations, so I’ll be a giant p*ssy and say that I do not have all of the answers, and some/all of my assumptions may be proven incorrect. I hope that you ENJOY the post, in all of its glorious warmongering.
4 Comments »